Roll Call: Guillotine, Dead of Winter, Mansions of Madness 

Roll Call summarizes the past week’s gaming exploits, and who was doing the exploiting. This past two weeks had 6 gaming sessions. The highlights are reported here. Mansions of Madness spoilers at the very bottom of the post below the poll.  Don’t forget Seth’s suggested poll about your favourite zombie game near the bottom.

Wednesday & Friday School Games Club: 25 Kids Combined

Guillotine (1998, BGG 6.4)


20 Minutes, 3 Players, Time includes teaching the two newbies I played with  Lay out a line of 12 nobles per day for each of the three days of the French Revolution. As rival executioners of the people, before the mandatory collection of the nobel’s head at the front of the line, you can use one of your five action cards to rearrange the line and screw your opponent to best advantage. Most points worth of nobles at the end of three days wins.

Guillotine Nobel Deck

All heads are not created equal

Light and fluffy, this game is easy to teach, plays well with between 2 and 6 players, people can join and leave mid-game without too much fuss, and nobody gets eliminated before the final scores are tallied. A near perfect lunchtime club game if it wasn’t for the fact you’re cutting off heads all the time. You can always tell the kids you’re ‘saving’ the nobel at the front of the line. Guillotine will, however, not satisfy the rivet or bean counters in your game group who want to be able to clearly calculate and plot a course to victory. There’s too much luck in how the nobles are dealt out and which action cards you get to make this a real strategy game. Strictly pop and pretzels but tasty nonetheless.

Thursday Night Coop Game Group:  4 Players

Dead of Winter (2014, BGG 7.73) Raiding Party Scenario – Empty 2 locations of all item cards

60 Minutes  After playing the first scenario of Dead of Winter again last game night, we were able to get in a more advanced scenario this time around.  My opinion remains positive and everyone seemed to enjoy it.  We lost quite badly as we were about half finished our overall objective when we lost a survivor (mine), lost a morale, and lost the game. However, once again, the game delivered a really fun and tense cooperative experience with even more gritty choices than last time. Spoiler, this time we didn’t turn the horse into food (but probably should have).

I’d recommend this game along with the dice version of Pandemic: The Cure  as easy ways to turn new gamers on to cooperative games or cater to groups that don’t like head-to-head competition. Dead of Winter checks all the boxes: easy to teach, predictable play time, limited down time even with 4 or 5 players. With an expansion out now and the ability to pick it up cheaply from on-line retailers or the odd lucky find at a Geek Garage Sale, it is highly recommended.

Warning, Mansion of Madness spoilers below the poll. It shows the first Cycle of Eternity adventure final game board set up, but that’s it.

 Family Day Holiday Monday: 3 Players

Mansions of Madness 2nd Ed. (2016, BGG 7.7) Cycle of Eternity Adventure

2.5 Hours  We broke out Mansions of Madness on Family day Monday. It was the first time I’ve played with my wife and daughter. They caught on quick and we ended up winning the opening adventure, although two of us never made it out of the mansion. It was interesting to get a take on the game from recreational gamers (as opposed to diehards).

Both like the eerie setting and soundtrack as well as their role in playing an investigator Family Day Mansions of Madnesssolving a mystery. The app didn’t get in the way at all and, as before, allowed me to just teach and play the game without any bookkeeping. There were brief moments of frustration with having only two actions per turn. It seems unnatural to double move to get to a door, then pause for a mythos phase before opening it. We quickly got over that and into the rhythm of the game.

The cooperative nature of the game was also a winner. We enjoyed being on the same team with all the cheering each other on and the sense of accomplishment that entails. We liked our characters and quickly learned to take advantage of their  special abilities. The individual aspect of the game was also a winner.

The final verdict is that everyone wants to play again. That says it all.

One Comment on “ Roll Call: Guillotine, Dead of Winter, Mansions of Madness 

Have your say here!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: